New Complaint Filed by HOP Against Apple for Planned Obsolescence and Obstruction of Repairs
On Wednesday, December 7, 2022, the organization HOP – Stop Planned Obsolescence filed a complaint with the public prosecutor against the Apple Group.

The accredited environmental protection organization is once again targeting the world’s leading smartphone manufacturer, following the record fine of 25 million euros imposed on the company in 2020 after a complaint filed by HOP.

This new complaint targets an increasingly widespread practice by the manufacturer: serialization (also known as “pairing”), which involves linking the serial numbers of a product’s components and peripherals to that of the iPhone, primarily through microchips. This practice has recently begun to affect the parts most prone to failure (screens, batteries, cameras, etc.).

It allows the manufacturer to limit repair options, particularly for unauthorized repair shops. In many cases documented in the complaint, malfunctions have been observed when the device is repaired using a part—even if it is identical and genuine—that is not authorized by Apple’s software.

Apple repair-friendly or not ?
More to read
Apple in 2024: a truly repair-friendly multinational?

These issues can also be triggered by an update (as in the recent case of a repaired touchscreen on an iPhone XR that became inoperable after the iOS 16 update). While simply reverting to iOS 15 would fix this issue, Apple does not allow it, preferring instead to blame a “non-Apple-genuine screen that is causing a touchscreen issue.”

These practices not only undermine the right to repair, but also hinder the growth of the smartphone refurbishment industry, since devices returned to circulation may experience current or future malfunctions. The complaint filed by HOP includes a nearly sixty-page case presentation that provides grounds to prosecute Apple on several counts: misleading commercial practices (notably through a failure to inform consumers) and offenses equivalent to planned obsolescence.

On this point, the complaint focuses in particular on the new offenses established by the Anti-Waste Law for a Circular Economy (2020), condemning the restrictions on repair and refurbishment outside of authorized channels, as well as the restrictions on access to spare parts and information—including software—necessary for repairing an iPhone (Articles L. 441-3 and L. 441-4 of the Consumer Code).

For the HOP association, the recurring malfunctions—which occur without any information or solutions being provided to consumers or repair technicians—are not mere “bugs.” They are intended to discourage independent repairs or refurbishment in favor of the sale of new smartphones or manufacturer-authorized repairs, often at prices that are prohibitive for consumers.

The stakes are high, both for the environment and for consumers. Nearly 4 million iPhones are sold each year in France. However, nearly 80% of a smartphone’s environmental footprint is generated during its manufacturing, which is why repair and refurbishment are of immense ecological importance. For consumers, extending the useful life of smartphones also leads to substantial savings in purchasing power.

"
At a time when Apple boasts about its environmental initiatives, our role is to expose the scandalous waste it actually perpetuates
Laëtitia Vasseur
Co-founder and Executive Director of HOP

Samuel Sauvage, co-founder of the association, adds: “If Apple wants to hinder independent repairs and the growth of the refurbished market, the courts must put a stop to these anachronistic, irresponsible, and illegal practices. ”

For the HOP association, the time has come to defend the right to repair and address these strategies to prevent them from spreading to other products.

Help us maintain our
independence!