HOP is pleased to learn that the Public Prosecutor of Paris has opened an investigation and hopes that, thanks to the The Directorate General for Competition Policy, Consumer Affairs and Fraud Control (DGCCRF), under the French Ministry of Economic Affairs and Finance, this will lead to sanctions and demonstrate the criminal nature of the serialization practices challenged by the association. An initial complaint filed by HOP resulted in Apple paying 25 million euros to the French Treasury in 2020. The latest development in the so-called “Batterygate” scandal could once again leave the company facing a record fine in the United Kingdom.
A Lawsuit Alleging Planned Obsolescence and Obstruction of Repairs
Filed on December 7, 2022, HOP’s new lawsuit against Apple invokes new offenses created to effectively combat planned obsolescence and guarantee the right to repair—offenses that have never before been invoked, such as intentional irreparability.
In this complaint, supported by numerous facts, HOP specifically alerts the courts to the harm caused by an increasingly widespread practice: serialization (or “pairing”). This involves linking the serial numbers of replacement parts to that of a smartphone—primarily through microchips—enabling the manufacturer to restrict repairs by unauthorized repair shops or to remotely disable a smartphone repaired with “generic” parts.
The association therefore believes that Apple could be creating numerous obstacles to repairs, contrary to what its communications suggest—particularly regarding the “Self Service Repair” program, which in practice turns out to be expensive and absurd (for example, you have to order two 35-kg tool cases just to repair a battery).
The Enormous Environmental and Social Impact of Serialization
Serialization, the unavailability of replacement parts at reasonable prices and within reasonable timeframes (outside the authorized channel), and unexplained defects following updates… these are all questionable practices that suggest the manufacturer is primarily focused on selling ever more equipment, at the expense of consumers and the environment.
For HOP, these strategies undermine not only the right to repair, but also the democratization of refurbishment and, more broadly, the development of the circular economy.
Repair and reuse are, however, a priority—as required, in fact, by French and European standards—and are already widespread practices in sectors such as home appliances and automobiles, particularly through access to generic and secondhand parts and repairs outside of authorized service channels. Keep in mind that using your smartphone for one more year reduces its environmental footprint by 25%, and that buying a refurbished smartphone instead of a new one can reduce its environmental impact by a factor of 8 and cut the cost by up to 75%.
With one month to go before VivaTech, the major event for technological innovation, HOP is calling on smartphone manufacturers—and Apple in particular—to use their “radical innovations” to create devices that are both reliable and repairable by anyone.