This was highly anticipated news for the HOP — Stop Planned Obsolescence. In its complaint filed on December 7, 2022, the association alerted the courts to the harm caused by a practice: serialization or part pairing.
Apple will be prosecuted in the Paris Criminal Court for using techniques—including software—designed to hinder the repair and reconditioning of several models of iPhones outside its authorized channels.
The first pretrial hearing will take place on February 25, 2027, and the trial will be held over several days at the end of June 2027.
The decision by representatives of the Public Prosecutor’s Office to press charges against Apple follows a four-year investigation and reflects the seriousness with which they now treat conduct aimed at unduly restricting the repair and refurbishment of electrical and electronic products.
In France, restrictions on refurbishment and repair outside the manufacturer’s authorized channels constitute a specific offense linked to planned obsolescence. Such obstructions have been prohibited since 2021 under Article L441-3 of the french Consumer Code, with the aim of protecting the environment and consumers.
iPhone Models involved in the complaint
2027 will be a significant year in the association’s long-term fight against the various forms that obsolescence takes. With the announced lawsuit against Apple, this marks the first time the Public Prosecutor’s Office has invoked the specific offense of obstructing repair and refurbishment, and the second time French courts have had to rule on practices of planned obsolescence in the broad sense. As a reminder, following a complaint filed by the HOP association in 2017, the printer and ink cartridge manufacturer Epson is being prosecuted before the Nanterre Criminal Court, in particular for practices of planned obsolescence.
Apple trial : Focus on serialization
What does this industrial practice entail—one that is spreading across various economic sectors, such as the digital and automotive industries—and which HOP views as an obstacle to repair and reconditioning?
As defined by HOP, serialization is a practice prohibited by the Consumer Code (Article L441-3). It involves linking the serial numbers of a product’s components
(such as those of an iPhone) primarily via microchips, to detect when one of these components is replaced and to cause malfunctions when a technician not authorized by the company performs the replacement. The Association has even detected malfunctions when a device is repaired with an identical, genuine part, provided that the repair is not authorized by Apple, affecting—for several years—the parts most frequently prone to failure (screens, batteries, cameras, etc.).
Product serialization provides manufacturers with the technical means to limit repair options outside their network, particularly by unauthorized repairers. It also indirectly limits access to repairs at affordable prices.
“Serialization” is gaining ground despite efforts to combat waste.
Although Apple has announced that, announced that, from 2022, it would limit serialization practices on new iPhone and now allows third parties to have certain repairs validated, these improvements remain to be confirmed over time. For HOP, this development reflects a gradual recognition of the serious challenges posed by serialization for repair and refurbishment outside of authorized channels. Alerted to these risks, European and U.S. lawmakers have taken the initiative and established stricter regulations, for example through the Right to Repair Directive.
Their spare parts … Our evidence
HOP calls on the general public to take action against barriers to repair and other practices that deprive us of our belongings. We no longer want to pay the double price—economic and environmental—of planned obsolescence.
To fight back and stand united behind HOP ahead of the trial against a multinational corporation that posted US$112 billion in profits in 2025 in profits by 2025, we call on you to sign our manifesto, “Their Spare Parts, Our Evidence.”